The Independent - UK February 8, 2011
Sect scandal: Scientologists outraged by defector's claims
Film-maker causes furore with magazine allegations about secret FBI 'investigation'
By Guy Adams in Los Angeles
Leaders of the Church of Scientology last night launched a vigorous defence of their organisation and their treatment of the faith's adherents amid what they described as "sensationalist" claims they have been under investigation by an FBI task force on human trafficking.
The move came after Paul Haggis, an Oscar-winning screenwriter who renounced Scientology in 2009 after 34 years as a member, broke a long public silence to help the New Yorker magazine compile a lengthy investigation into the Church's affairs. [see previous post on this blog or first link in Related Articles section below]
Some of the most extraordinary claims raised by the 25,000-word article, published at midnight on Sunday, centre on the Church's chairman, David Miscavige, who was best man at Tom Cruise's wedding. He is accused of a number of incidents of threatening behaviour towards followers.
Others revolve around "Sea Org", an order of followers who work as full-time activists at its churches, celebrity centres and missions around the world. The apparent FBI investigation, which the Church says it is unaware of, is believed to focus on Gold Base, a Scientology headquarters near the desert town of Hemet, several hours drive south-east of Los Angeles.
The fenced property is home to about 800 members of Sea Org, as well as film production facilities for the Church's PR wing. It is also where Miscavige keeps an office. According to the New Yorker, which has interviewed several dozen former Scientologists as well as Haggis, leaders there are encouraged "to instil aggressive, even violent, discipline".
Quoting an estranged ex-Scientologist called Mark Rathbun, the magazine claims punishments at Gold Base include being sent to the "Hole", a pair of trailers. "There were between eighty and a hundred people sentenced to the Hole at that time," Rathbun claimed. "We were required to do group confessions all day and all night."
The magazine alleges that Tricia Whitehill, an FBI agent stationed in Los Angeles – home to the Church of Scientology's Hollywood "celebrity centre", where many of its most famous members worship – flew to Florida in December 2009 to interview former Scientologists about their experiences at Gold Base. According to the article, the case remains open.
Church leaders deny the existence of places of confinement at any of their properties and say they told the New Yorker they had never been advised of any government investigation. "The article is little more than a regurgitation of old allegations which have long been disproved," said a statement from its spokesman, Tommy Davis.
"It is disappointing that a magazine with the reputation of the New Yorker chose to reprint these sensationalist claims from disaffected former members hardly worthy of a tabloid," he said, further criticising the publication for deciding to "use the claim of an 'investigation' to garner headlines for an otherwise stale article containing nothing but rehashed unfounded allegations." It added that the claims had been raised in a lawsuit dismissed by a US federal judge.
Mr Davis, a son of the actress Anne Archer, was once close to Paul Haggis, who tells the New Yorker how he became a Scientologist in the 1970s after a street salesman persuaded him to buy a copy of a book on “Dianetics” written by the Church’s founder, the late science fiction author L Ron Hubbard.
"There was a feeling of camaraderie that was something I'd never experienced," says Haggis, who wrote Crash, Million Dollar Baby, and the last two James Bond films. "I was in a cult for 34 years. Everyone else could see it. I don't know why I couldn't."
Haggis has a lesbian daughter, and tells how he quit the Church in 2009 amid a row about its role in supporting Proposition 8, the ballot measure which banned gay marriage in California. He estimated he gave several hundred thousand dollars to Scientology during his years as a member.
Others who contributed to the New Yorker piece included Hollywood actor Josh Brolin. He recalled once attending a dinner party at which John Travolta, a prominent Scientologist, practiced a form of spiritual healing on Marlon Brando, which involved laying hands on a flesh wound. A spokesman for Mr Travolta has called the claim "total fabrication".
This article was found at:
By Joe Childs and Thomas C. Tobin, Times Staff Writers
FBI agents investigating human trafficking have interviewed several high-ranking defectors from the Church of Scientology who spoke out to the St. Petersburg Times over the past two years about abusive and coercive practices within the church.
Five former church staffers confirmed Monday that the FBI interviewed them individually over the past 15 months about their experiences in the church's religious order, the Sea Org.
They said agents asked detailed questions primarily about working and living conditions at Scientology's remote international management base in the desert east of Los Angeles. The defectors — Amy Scobee, Mike Rinder, Tom DeVocht, Jeff Hawkins and Gary Morehead — said they described to agents how Sea Org staffers were restricted to the compound, intimidated, degraded and coerced to work long hours for little pay.
The defectors' account of life inside Scientology first appeared in the Timesin a 2009 investigative series titled The Truth Rundown.
The church has emphatically denied that any staffers were mistreated and says the defectors were lying when they claimed that church leader David Miscavige physically attacked managers whose work performance displeased him.
News of an FBI investigation broke early Monday on the website of theNew Yorker magazine. Investigative journalist Lawrence Wright presents in the current issue a lengthy profile of former Scientology parishioner Paul Haggis, an Academy Award winning screenwriter and film director who left the church in 2009, citing a range of concerns, among them the revelations reported in the Truth Rundown.
Wright reported that former Scientology executive Scobee, former international base security chief Morehead and DeVocht, a former church manager in Clearwater, all were interviewed by the FBI as part of a human trafficking investigation he characterized as ongoing.
On Monday, Scientology spokesman Tommy Davis said that the New Yorkerarticle was "nothing but a rehash of unfounded allegations" and that the church "has never been advised of any government investigation."
Laura Eimiller, an FBI spokeswoman in Los Angeles, said she could neither confirm nor deny the existence of the investigation.
On Monday, Scobee, Rinder and DeVocht told the Times that Los Angeles-based Special Agent Tricia Whitehill traveled to Clearwater to interview them at the FBI's office on Cleveland Street.
Scobee said Whitehill interviewed her for two days, Dec. 3 and 4, 2009. She said the agent asked about several topics, including instances of physical violence Scobee witnessed and punishments like the Rehabilitation Project Force or "RPF," a labor detail in which Sea Org members who transgress can work their way back into the church's good graces.
Scobee described RPFs as camps where staffers can languish for years, separated from friends, spouses and other family and given low quality food and living quarters.
She said she first came in contact with the FBI after she sent the agency copies of affidavits and other documents the church had given the Times and ABC News Nightline in 2009. The church offered the materials as proof Miscavige never hit anyone. But the documents — including sworn statements by current Scientology executives — acknowledged that violence occurred within the church's top management.
"They are admitting under penalty of perjury that it's happening with wild abandon," Scobee said. "None of them are calling the police. It needs intervention because they somehow think it's okay."
Shortly after Scobee sent the documents to the FBI, the agency called her, said it had an ongoing investigation into Scientology and arranged to meet with her, she said.
While in the Clearwater FBI office for her interview, Scobee said, Whitehill cautioned her not to speak with other employees in the office. She said Whitehill indicated the office might be compromised when it came to Scientology.
She said Whitehill also interviewed her husband, Mat Pesch, a longtime church staffer in Clearwater who defected with her in 2005.
Scobee said she gave the FBI a long list of contact information for people who had left the international base and was impressed that the agency had already interviewed some of them.
Asked why she decided to talk about the investigation now, despite the FBI's request that she remain quiet, Scobee said: "I didn't hear anything for a year and I got fed up. They're either going to do something or they're not."
Rinder, the former church spokesman, said he met with Whitehill in Clearwater for five hours. He detailed restrictions placed in 2006 on about 75 church managers who, Rinder said, were prevented from leaving their office complex, a pair of conjoined double-wide trailers that the managers gave the derisive nickname "the Hole.''
For months, Rinder and his colleagues slept on the floor, working well into the night, getting to leave only to shower once a day, Rinder said.
He said Whitehill's questions focused on work practices that can constitute human trafficking under the law. He said he related that Sea Org members assigned to the international base did not have easy access to telephones, that their passports were confiscated and that they were not free to leave the base, which is guarded and bordered by a chain-link fence topped with razor wire.
Rinder said the agent asked whether he believed staffers had been coerced into thinking they would be harmed if they tried to leave. His answer: "Yeah, of course.''
Rinder headed the church's Office of Special Affairs for two decades before running away in March 2007 while on assignment in London. He lived in Denver, working as a car salesman, before moving to Pinellas in late 2009. He now does consulting work and public relations.
Toward the end of 2010, he said he had the sense the FBI's investigation had lost momentum or, perhaps, had been shelved. But he added that Whitehill told him more than once, "Oh, we're still going.''
DeVocht is one of the few church managers to successfully flee the international base. Fed up with what he described as humiliating and degrading treatment of himself and others, he jumped over the front gate in 2005 and walked the 6 miles to nearby Hemet, Calif., eventually making his way to Florida, where his family lived before he joined the Sea Org at 14.
Now living in Oldsmar and selling furniture, DeVocht supervised church facilities in Clearwater before being assigned to the California base in the early 2000s. His interview with Whitehill ran about 90 minutes, he said. The agent posed specific, informed questions.
"Obviously, she had a ton of information,'' DeVocht said. "A lot of what I said confirmed what she had already heard.''
Like Rinder, he said he described conditions inside "the Hole'' as well as the wire-topped perimeter fence and patrolling guards. He said Whitehill asked: Were the barriers and guards to keep the staff in or to prevent outsiders from getting in?
"To keep them in,'' he said.
Jeff Hawkins, a former international base staffer who worked on major marketing campaigns, said Whitehill and another agent, Valerie Venegas, interviewed him early last year at the FBI's office in downtown Portland, Ore. "It was pretty much a full day," he said, remembering that he recounted episodes of physical violence by Miscavige and life in the RPF, among other topics. The agents sounded "very knowledgeable" about conditions in the church, Hawkins said.
Morehead, the former security chief, also met with the agents in Portland. He said they asked about a drill he helped devise to retrieve staffers who had "blown" — left without permission. They also asked about female staffers who he said had been pressured to get abortions.
Under federal and state statutes, human trafficking doesn't necessarily involve people being held by physical force. Traffickers can use emotional buttons, intimidation and financial ties to control people.
The FBI's website says there are many signs of human trafficking, but some include:
• Physical, emotional and verbal abuse, or submissiveness.
• A person's food being controlled by someone else.
• A person not speaking on his or her own behalf.
• Lack of control over one's schedule, money, identification and travel documents.
• People living and working in the same place.
• A debt owed to an employer/crew leader, or a perceived inability to leave a job.
The church won a major victory against two human trafficking claims last August when a federal judge in Los Angeles threw out two lawsuits filed against the church by former Sea Org members Claire and Marc Headley, a married couple living in Burbank.
The Headleys, now in their mid 30s, had joined the Sea Org as teenagers. Both were assigned to the desert base, where they met and married, as is common among the hundreds of staffers working there. They escaped separately in early 2005 and were pursued by church security teams, but outmaneuvered them.
The Headleys filed separate suits in January, 2009, alleging they were victims of forced labor. Claire Headley's suit also alleged she had two abortions under pressure from the church, lest she lose her standing in the Sea Org, which discourages members from having children. The church denied pressuring her and said the abortions were Headley's decision.
In dismissing their suits, a judge ruled that the Headleys performed religious duties and that the Sea Org, as a religious order, falls within the "ministerial exception'' commonly granted to religious groups in employment cases. The exception prevents the court from digging into internal church workings to explore the Headleys' claims, the judge said.
Reached Monday, Claire Headley said she and her husband would not discuss whether they have spoken to FBI investigators.
St. Petersburg Times - Florida February 11, 2011
Vigorous investigation of Scientology needed
A Times Editorial
Finally, it appears that law enforcement officials have taken an interest in the Church of Scientology's intimidation and harassment of its workers. Former Scientology staffers confirmed to the St. Petersburg Times this week that they have been interviewed by FBI agents over the past two years about their treatment while working for the church. While there are considerable legal and practical hurdles to overcome, federal investigators should conduct a vigorous, thorough review of the church's well-reported abuse of its workers.
There is plenty for the FBI to investigate. A Times' 2009 investigative series revealed the accounts of former members of the Sea Org, Scientology's labor force. They lifted the veil of secrecy and detailed how they were required to work extraordinary hours, deprived of sleep and punished if they did not meet expectations. If they attempted to leave without permission, they often were pursued by church officials. If they returned, they often were punished and forced to endure lengthy stints of manual labor, limited food and enforced silence under heavy security.
The willingness of those former Scientology staffers to publicly tell their stories had a positive impact. They encouraged others tied to Scientology to raise questions and speak out, such as former Scientology parishioner Paul Haggis. A prominent screenwriter and film director who left the church in 2009, Haggis was a key figure in a lengthy New Yorker magazine story this week by investigative journalist Lawrence Wright. The first public word of the FBI investigation came when the magazine story was posted on the New Yorker website, and five former church staffers then publicly confirmed to the Times that they have been interviewed by the FBI over the past 15 months. The church denies any wrongdoing or that staffers were mistreated, despite a growing number of former church members who are speaking out publicly.
The former church staffers told the newspaper that agents asked about conditions at a remote desert church base east of Los Angeles. They said they recounted how Sea Org staffers were compelled to stay on the base, intimidated and forced to work for little pay. Yet the legal difficulties in pursuing a criminal investigation against an organization with the tax-exempt status of a religious institution are considerable. Just how vigorously the FBI is investigating the Church of Scientology also is unclear.
If the investigation is ongoing, the FBI should pursue it with its full range of resources and deliberate speed. If its inquiry is closed without any charges, the agency has an obligation to inform the church and the public. The public accounts of life inside the church are worthy of attention by law enforcement, regardless of the church's denials. But ultimately, the best hope for a full accounting of the Church of Scientology's activities and any real change may come from former church members who summon the courage to speak out against the institution they once embraced.
Expose of Scientology by Paul Haggis promises to be "most profound reckoning to date" of the abusive cult
Scientology cult hides abuses behind fancy new 'church' fronts, claims millions of adherents despite declining membership
The abuse behind Scientology's facade
Scientology Exposed Once Again By Insiders: A smiling storefront, a darker interior
Tom Cruise practiced Scientology indoctrination techniques on isolated, vulnerable teenager
Riddle of John Travolta's son - could he have been saved?
Scientology critics cite 2007 prediction of Jett Travolta's death
Did John Travolta’s weird faith seal his son Jett’s fate?
More on Jett Travolta: an audio recording of L. Ron Hubbard talking about epilepsy
John Travolta Admits Son Jett Suffered From Autism
Death of John Travolta's son "deeply shaken" his faith in the Scientology cult
Mom sues Church of Scientology in son's death
Scientology Endangers Children [video]
New website "Ex-Scientology Kids" now online
Niece of Scientology Leader Rebuts Claims of Family Values
Niece of Scientology leader describes how her own family was broken apart by the movement’s policies.
Daughter of Scientology leaders in Australia describes it as a toxic organization that treats children like cattle
Video interview by Steve Hassan of top ex-Scientologist at international cult conference in New York
Ex-Scientology lawsuits target Sea Org, a cult within a cult
Australian TV airs new evidence of coerced abortions and child exploitation in Scientology cult
Survivor of Scientology abuse speaks out on her life as a "child slave" after Australian parliament refuses to investigate "dangerous pseudo-religion"
Scientology's intimidation tactics led to suicide of Australian member, family urges parliamentary probe
Former Scientology film production employees allege labor violations
New lawsuit alleges child labor and exploitation in totalitarian Scientology compound
Ex-Scientologists speak about abuse and lawsuits on anniversary of global protests against sci-fi cult
Was Scientology's efforts to suppress online revelations of the Xenu story the beginning of the end for sci-fi cult?