New York Times - March 8, 2011
21 Priests Suspended in Philadelphia
By KATHARINE Q. SEELYE
The Archdiocese of Philadelphia announced Tuesday that it had suspended 21 priests from active ministry in connection with accusations that involved sexual abuse or otherwise inappropriate behavior with minors.
The mass suspension was the single-most sweeping in the history of the sexual-abuse scandal in the Roman Catholic Church in the United States, said Terence McKiernan, president of BishopAccountability.org, which archives documents from the abuse scandal in dioceses across the country.
The archdiocese’s action follows a damning grand jury report issued Feb. 10 that accused the archdiocese of a widespread cover-up of predatory priests, stretching over decades, and said that as many as 37 priests remained active in the ministry despite credible accusations against them.
Of those 37 priests, 21 were suspended; three others already had been placed on administrative leave after the grand jury detailed accusations against them. Five others would have been suspended, the church said in a statement, but three are no longer active and two are no longer active in the Philadelphia Archdiocese. The church said that in eight cases, no further investigation was warranted.
The statement said the accusations against the 21 ranged from “sexual abuse of a minor to boundary issues with minors,” but did not describe them further.
Nor did it name the 21 whom it suspended, drawing the fury of groups representing abuse victims. Many parishioners are likely to learn that their priest was accused when he fails to appear for Ash Wednesday services.
The announcement was a major embarrassment for Cardinal Justin Rigali, who, in response to the grand jury report, had initially said there were no priests in active ministry “who have an admitted or established allegation of sexual abuse of a minor against them.”
A few days later, Cardinal Rigali placed three priests on administrative leave. His statement Tuesday did not explain why he had made his initial assurances nor did it say why the priests had not been suspended earlier.
“We may have to be asking, what did the cardinal know and when did he know it?” said Leonard Norman Primiano, a Roman Catholic and chairman of the religious studies department at Cabrini College in nearby Radnor, Pa. He described the mass suspension as “astonishing.”
At a minimum, the scope of the suspensions underscored the grand jury’s contention that the archdiocese had failed to clean house after a grand jury report in 2005 found credible accusations of abuse by 63 priests. And it suggested that potentially, predatory priests had had access to thousands of children for years.
The grand jury report prompted the indictment last month of four priests and a parochial school teacher. They include Msgr. William Lynn, the first senior church official in the United States to face criminal charges of covering up abusive behavior.
Cardinal Rigali, 75, said the suspensions were interim measures, pending fuller investigations. And he apologized for the behavior of abusive priests.
“I am truly sorry for the harm done to the victims of sexual abuse, as well as to the members of our community who suffer as a result of this great evil and crime,” he said. He is expected to address the issue Wednesday in a noon service at the Cathedral Basilica of SS. Peter and Paul. He has scheduled a penitential service for Friday.
Those on leave are not allowed to celebrate Mass publicly, wear collars or hear confessions. They were given a few hours’ notice to leave their parishes before the announcement.
Once the identities of the suspended priests become public, analysts said, there could be a dam-breaking effect as there was in Boston in 2002, when initial reports led to more sexual-abuse claims. Since the grand jury report in Philadelphia, two people have filed civil suits, and Jeff Anderson, a lawyer representing them, said he had received “dozens” of calls from others who might file.
“We’re approaching this with a new vigor,” Mr. Anderson said. “Like Boston, this is a watershed moment, where all of a sudden the secrets are no longer kept and permission is given to break the silence to this whole survivors’ community.”
If charges against the priests are upheld, the church could face a payout of millions of dollars in legal settlements. The charges come at a stressful time for the church, with membership and parochial school enrollment declining. The archdiocese announced last week that it was closing seven schools in June; it has already closed more than 40 since 2006.
This article has been revised to reflect the following correction:
Correction: March 9, 2011
An earlier version of this article misidentified a lawyer represending two people who have filed civil suits after the grand jury report in Philadelphia. The lawyer is Jeff Anderson, not Jeff Armstrong.
Three Philadelphia priests and teacher charged with raping boys, Monsignor charged with failing to protect children
US lawyer behind 1500 lawsuits against Catholic church opens new firm in London to pursue cross-Atlantic cases
Hundreds of admitted or credibly accused pedophile priests who escaped justice are unsupervised by church or police
Case of pedophile priest protected by UK's top Catholic puts lie to apologist claims that clergy sex crimes are all historic
Pope refers to clergy sex crimes as "recently" emerging in speech to trainee priests, ignoring centuries of abuse
New cases of recent sex crimes against minors by Catholic bishops emerge in Texas, Canada and Norway
New Catholic child abuse cases surface in Austria, Germany, Switzerland and the Netherlands
Jesuit sex abuse scandal in German school just "the tip of the iceberg" says principle, but survivors have few legal options
Boston Globe reporters who exposed widespread sex crimes scandal which led to current Catholic crisis say far more yet to come
Current wave of global Catholic scandals just tip of iceberg says Quebec advocate who predicts many more to come
As Vatican cardinal defends pope and church, African bishop says sex crimes of priests there not yet exposed
Catholic scandals grow in Latin America, senior Brazilian priest arrested for sex crimes after congressional investigation
Leaked confidential letter reveals Vatican's intention to prevent reporting of abuse to criminal authorities
Of course popes, cardinals and bishops covered up crimes against children, but can the Church be reformed while leaders are in denial?
Former Jesuit priest finally charged with child abuse for assaulting two students in 2004 and 2009
Dutch bishops admit they did not warn diocese of pedophile priest, Cardinal denies knowledge of abuse and Vatican cover-up
Investigation uncovers Catholic practice of "geographic cure", shuffling pedophile priests around the globe
Vatican officials, including future pope, refused to defrock "evil, remorseless sociopath" priest until 9 years after his first conviction for sex crimes
New York priest defrocked for child sex abuse after 8 year church judicial process that excluded victim's rights
Catholic church spends millions protecting predators and keeping victims out of court by fighting time limits law reform
Catholic church fights New Jersey bill that would reform statute of limitations and expand liability to supervisors of children
New Jersey childhood sexual abuse statute of limitations law upheld
U.K. Catholic child protection head says Vatican response inadequate, statute of limitations ignore long term effects of abuse
Law suits against Catholic church for fraud and negligence in sex abuse cases attempt to overcome restrictive statute of limitations
Documents in Nova Scotia clergy abuse case reveal why statute of limitations for child sexual abuse should be eliminated
Canadian Supreme Court rules woman's lawsuit against Catholic Church can proceed despite expired time limit
Pope Benedict promises to better protect children in future, while New York Bishops fight to deny compensation to past victims
Tennessee clergy abuse survivors seek justice for crimes committed by pedophile priests and end to time limits
Episcopal bishop who covered up youth minister's sex abuse of minor reinstated due to church time limits
Child sex abuse inquiry finds Ontario church and gov't institutions revictimized survivors seeking help
Australian clergy abuse survivors say they are being re-victimized by compensation process and Catholic hierarchy
U.S. clergy abuse survivors group, SNAP, goes global to address worldwide crisis of abuse and cover-up