New York Times - March 4, 2011
In Philadelphia, New Cases Loom in Priest Scandal
By KATHARINE Q. SEELYE
PHILADELPHIA — Three weeks after a scathing grand jury report said the Archdiocese of Philadelphia had provided safe haven to as many as 37 priests who were credibly accused of sexual abuse or inappropriate behavior toward minors, most of those priests remain active in the ministry.
The possibility that even one predatory priest, not to mention three dozen, might still be serving in parishes — “on duty in the archdiocese today, with open access to new young prey,” as the grand jury put it — has unnerved many Roman Catholics here and sent the church reeling in the latest and one of the most damning episodes in the American church since it became engulfed in the sexual abuse scandal nearly a decade ago.
The situation in Philadelphia is “Boston reborn,” said David J. O’Brien, who teaches Catholic history at the University of Dayton. The Boston Archdiocese was engulfed in a scandal starting in 2002 involving widespread sexual abuse by priests and an extensive cover-up that reached as high as the cardinal.
Some parishioners say they feel discouraged and are caught in a wave of anxiety, even as they continue to attend Mass.
“It’s a tough day to be a faith-filled Catholic,” Maria Shultz, 43, a secretary at Immaculata University, said after Mass last weekend at St. Joseph’s Church in suburban Downingtown.
But Mrs. Shultz, who has four daughters, expressed no doubt about how the church should deal with the 37 priests. “They should be removed immediately,” she said.
The church has not explained directly why these priests, most of whom were not publicly identified, are still active, though it is under intense pressure to do so. Cardinal Justin Rigali initially said there were no active priests with substantiated allegations against them, but six days later, he placed three of the priests, whose activities had been described in detail by the grand jury, on administrative leave.
He also hired an outside lawyer, Gina Maisto Smith, a former assistant district attorney who prosecuted child sexual assault cases for 15 years, to re-examine all cases involving priests in active ministry and review the procedures employed by the archdiocese.
“There is a tremendous sense of urgency here,” Mrs. Smith said in an interview this week at the archdiocese, where she said she and a team had been working around the clock, without interference from the church hierarchy. “They’ve given me the freedom and the independence to conduct a thorough review,” she said, with “unfettered access to files.”
She added that announcements about her initial review would be coming “sooner rather than later.”
“The urgency is to respond to that concern over the 37, what that means, how that number was derived and what to do in response to it,” she said.
Philadelphia is unusual in that the archdiocese has been the subject of not one but two grand jury reports. The first, in 2005, found credible accusations of abuse by 63 priests, whose activities had been covered up by the church. But there were no indictments, mainly because the statute of limitations had expired.
This time, the climate is different.
When the grand jury issued its report on Feb. 10, the district attorney immediately indicted two priests, Charles Engelhardt and James Brennan; a parochial school teacher, Bernard Shero; and a man who had left the priesthood, Edward Avery, on charges of rape or assault. All four are due in court on March 14. He also indicted Msgr. William Lynn on charges of endangering the welfare of children — the first time a senior church official has been charged with covering up abuse in the sex scandal in the United States.
When the archdiocese learns of reports of sexual abuse, it is now supposed to report them to the district attorney, which is what led to the most recent grand jury investigation. Extensions on the statute of limitations also made prosecutions possible this time.
But even with these changes, some were surprised to see the grand jury paint a picture of a church where serious problems still festered.
“The thing that is significant about Philadelphia is the assumption that the authorities had made changes and the system had been fixed,” said Terence McKiernan, the president of BishopAccountability.org, which archives documents from the abuse scandal in dioceses across the country. “But the headline is that in Philadelphia, the system is still broke.”
The grand jury said 20 of the active priests were accused of sexual abuse and 17 others were accused of “inappropriate behavior with minors.”
In response, Cardinal Rigali issued a statement the day of the report, saying, “I assure all the faithful that there are no archdiocesan priests in ministry today who have an admitted or established allegation of sexual abuse of a minor against them.”
The phrasing spoke directly to the church’s policy of “zero tolerance” of priests who sexually abuse minors. If any active priests have such allegations against them, the policy calls for their suspension until the charges are resolved.
Still, six days later, he placed three priests on administrative leave — a tacit acknowledgment that perhaps there were priests facing such accusations.
The uncertain fate of the 37 active priests, whose names the archdiocese turned over to the district attorney, all but guarantees a continuing spectacle here. So do the indictments, a flurry of civil suits against church officials, victims who continue to step forward and the potential for courtroom drama.
Three weeks into the scandal, the archdiocese said it was not clear how much the revelations had hurt attendance at Mass and donations. Daniel E. Thomas, an auxiliary bishop of Philadelphia, said he had heard both sides: some parishioners were attending church more to pray for the victims and “the good priests, the faithful priests,” and some have told him, “We’re angry, we’re confused and we’re distressed.”
He also said that some priests had told him that donations were not down but that he was aware of “at least a few people who have said, ‘I’m not going to be giving to the church’ ” and that some were not fulfilling their pledges to give to the church’s capital campaign. He said money for the capital campaign goes specifically to help the church fulfill its charitable mission; it cannot go toward the defense of priests or legal fees, he said, and so only the poor, the sick and the needy would suffer if those donations dried up.
Jon Hurdle contributed reporting.
Three Philadelphia priests and teacher charged with raping boys, Monsignor charged with failing to protect children
Washington archbishop claims Catholic clergy abuse is all historic, abusive priests now dealt with appropriately, but church still fights victims
Case of pedophile priest protected by UK's top Catholic puts lie to apologist claims that clergy sex crimes are all historic
Pope refers to clergy sex crimes as "recently" emerging in speech to trainee priests, ignoring centuries of abuse
New cases of recent sex crimes against minors by Catholic bishops emerge in Texas, Canada and Norway
New Catholic child abuse cases surface in Austria, Germany, Switzerland and the Netherlands
Jesuit sex abuse scandal in German school just "the tip of the iceberg" says principle, but survivors have few legal options
Boston Globe reporters who exposed widespread sex crimes scandal which led to current Catholic crisis say far more yet to come
Current wave of global Catholic scandals just tip of iceberg says Quebec advocate who predicts many more to come
As Vatican cardinal defends pope and church, African bishop says sex crimes of priests there not yet exposed
Catholic scandals grow in Latin America, senior Brazilian priest arrested for sex crimes after congressional investigation
Leaked confidential letter reveals Vatican's intention to prevent reporting of abuse to criminal authorities
Of course popes, cardinals and bishops covered up crimes against children, but can the Church be reformed while leaders are in denial?
Former Jesuit priest finally charged with child abuse for assaulting two students in 2004 and 2009
Dutch bishops admit they did not warn diocese of pedophile priest, Cardinal denies knowledge of abuse and Vatican cover-up
Investigation uncovers Catholic practice of "geographic cure", shuffling pedophile priests around the globe
Vatican officials, including future pope, refused to defrock "evil, remorseless sociopath" priest until 9 years after his first conviction for sex crimes
New York priest defrocked for child sex abuse after 8 year church judicial process that excluded victim's rights
Catholic church spends millions protecting predators and keeping victims out of court by fighting time limits law reform
Catholic church fights New Jersey bill that would reform statute of limitations and expand liability to supervisors of children
New Jersey childhood sexual abuse statute of limitations law upheld
U.K. Catholic child protection head says Vatican response inadequate, statute of limitations ignore long term effects of abuse
Law suits against Catholic church for fraud and negligence in sex abuse cases attempt to overcome restrictive statute of limitations
Documents in Nova Scotia clergy abuse case reveal why statute of limitations for child sexual abuse should be eliminated
Canadian Supreme Court rules woman's lawsuit against Catholic Church can proceed despite expired time limit
Pope Benedict promises to better protect children in future, while New York Bishops fight to deny compensation to past victims
Tennessee clergy abuse survivors seek justice for crimes committed by pedophile priests and end to time limits
Episcopal bishop who covered up youth minister's sex abuse of minor reinstated due to church time limits
Child sex abuse inquiry finds Ontario church and gov't institutions revictimized survivors seeking help
Australian clergy abuse survivors say they are being re-victimized by compensation process and Catholic hierarchy