11 Jan 2011
Irish priests say there is a difference between pedophile priests and those who commit "minor indiscretions" with a teenager
The Independent - Ireland October 27, 2010
Priests challenge policy on child abuse allegations
By John Cooney Religion Correspondent
THE Catholic Church authorities need to distinguish between a paedophile priest and the cleric who committed "a minor indiscretion" with a teenager 30 or more years ago, it was claimed yesterday.
At a private meeting in Claremorris, Co Mayo, yesterday, the new Association of Catholic Priests challenged the policy of Irish bishops requiring a priest to automatically step aside from office if a child abuse complaint or suspicion is lodged against the cleric.
They passed a resolution which throws down the gauntlet to the Irish Conference of Bishops and the Vatican.
Spokesman Father Tony Flannery, an outspoken Redemptorist priest, said many priests who attended the regional meeting expressed sympathy with colleagues who had been excluded from ministry even though their behaviour since the alleged complaint had been blameless.
The 45 priests spent a lot of the time debating how bishops and religious superiors handled allegations of child abuse levelled against colleagues. Last night Fr Flannery said there was a strong feeling that a distinction needed to be made between the paedophile and the man who had behaved inappropriately towards a teenager three decades ago.
He told the Irish Independent that the sexual advance by a priest on a child was damaging for the child, but he insisted that a distinction had to be made between the serial paedophile priest and the immature young cleric knowing nothing about sexuality who made a mistake.
This article was found at:
The Catholic League downplays the evils of child abuse
New book shows church's efforts to downplay crimes of Australian priest who terrorised and raped children for 50 years
Mother Teresa failed to protect teen boys from her spiritual adviser, the Jesuit order's most notorious convicted pedophile
Vatican Cardinal who handles clergy sex abuse cases once punished a priest who reported abuse, but not the abuser
Higher incidence of male victims of sex abuse in Anglican and Catholic churches than in the wider community
High-ranking priest criticizes standard of proof used by Wisconsin diocese to exonerate majority of accused clergy
Posted by Perry Bulwer at 14:58