29 Jan 2011

Quebec bans teaching a belief, a dogma or the practice of a specific religion in government subsidized daycares

Montreal Gazette - Canada December 17, 2010

Yolande James says subsidized daycares can't teach religion

Have until June 1 to phase out any religious teaching or risk losing subsidies


MONTREAL - Family Minister Yolande James announced a directive Friday ordering all operators of Quebec’s $7-a-day subsidized daycares to cease all religious instruction to children in their charge.

Daycares now dispensing religious instruction will have until June 1, 2011 to phase out religious teaching and if they do not comply they could have their government subsidy “suspended, reduced or cancelled.”

In an interview James drew a parallel with Quebec’s public schools, where religious instruction was ended, making them open to children of all origins.

“There needed to be clarification of what our subsidized daycare services would be allowed or not allowed to do,” James explained.

“As far as subsidized daycares are concerned, we cannot allow what’s called the transmission of faith or all teaching of religion within our subsidized daycares.”

But the ban on “teaching a belief, a dogma or the practice of a specific religion” in a daycare does not ban “cultural diversity or traditional or historical activities,” the minister said.

“Christmas trees, the menorah, and all of these symbols are allowed,” she said.

In issuing the directive, James is following up on a statement by her predecessor as family minister Tony Tomassi, who said in March that religious instruction in subsidized daycares would no longer be tolerated, after media attention focused on daycares dispensing Jewish and Islamic instruction.

Two religious daycares The Gazette contacted Friday would not comment on the directive.

James formed an advisory panel, to guide her in drawing up the directive, which included daycare associations, representatives of the religious daycares and a specialist in religion.

She recalled that in 1997 when Quebec started its subsidized daycare plan, her department agreed to subsidize existing religious daycares.

“Now we are at a different time,” she said. “The society has evolved. So has the community.”

She said the family department did not have a policy on religious instruction and did not have inspectors checking whether religion was being taught. But now her department has increased the number of inspectors.

Asked whether the constitutionality of her directive might be challenged in court, James said she is confident she is on solid legal ground.

“This directive was not in any way improvised,” she said.“It took the necessary time to look at he issues in all ways.”

This article was found at:



National Post - Canada December 30, 2010

Quebec worships the idol of secularism

by Father Raymond J. de Souza | National Post Columnist

It’s never too early to close the minds of the young. That’s the thinking of the provincial government in Quebec, which announced earlier this month a ban on religion in subsidized daycare centres.

Subsidized daycare is a central part of social policy in Quebec — parents pay $7/day, and provincial government pays the rest, which is about $40/day. The government of Quebec is now increasing its vigilance on what dangerous ideas the toddlers might be exposed to.

Just before Christmas, Family Minister Yolande James announced regulations that would seek to ban religion instruction from daycare centres that take government money. Given that four-year-olds are unlikely to be studying theology, the Quebec government is out to stamp out religious expressions — prayers, songs, bible stories, manger scenes and even explanations for religious dietary practices.

Strangely, you can have a manger scene — you just can’t tell the children who the figures are. The scene is cultural, but Jesus is religious. In a Jewish or Muslim daycare, presumably the children could keep dietary laws but not be told why. Children could decorate a Christmas tree (cultural) but not sing Silent Night (religious). It’s easy to mock the silliness of Quebec society when it comes to religion — the nanny-state cracks down on the nurseries! — but violations of religious liberty are no laughing matter. Quebec’s antipathy to expressions of Jewish and Islamic faith, combined with a deep self-loathing of its Catholic heritage, makes for a toxic combination.

“In Quebec, secularism has become the new religion,” said Daniel Amar, executive director of the Quebec Jewish Congress.

That’s almost right. It’s secular fundamentalism that the Quebec government practises, touched by a totalitarian impulse that brooks no dissent, even from little children who might need help in colouring their religious pictures.

Our editorial board argued on Tuesday that Quebec’s massive subsidies for approved daycare spaces has effectively crowded out non-subsidized daycare. The economic argument is clear — subsidize one form of child care over all others, and soon there will effectively be just one form of child care. Daycare has been de facto nationalized in Quebec, and the national religion of intolerant secularism will now be imposed.

The cultural question is more troubling. So serious is Quebec’s government about imposing its view on all children that, concurrent with the new regulations, it will triple the number of inspectors to enforce them. Quebec will soon have 58 inquisitors dropping in on daycares to ensure compliance. One can only imagine the scene when the inquisition arrives, sifting through the sandbox in search of clandestine religious items. And who will write the code for the bureaucrats, ensuring that miscreant daycare workers don’t mention that la fĂȘte nationale was once upon a time Saint-Jean-Baptiste?

There is an economic cost to big government. There is also a cultural cost, if everywhere government goes alternative values and viewpoints must retreat. If government goes everywhere, including the care of babies, then not even babies are entitled to hear views that dissent from government dogma. Quebec has long since abandoned the neutral state in favour of the aggressively secular state. Where the Quebec state goes, religion must retreat, and there is no limit on where the Quebec state will go.

The heart of every culture is its attitude to the big questions of human life and existence. That’s why a sensible people leaves culture in the hands of the churches, the artists, the musicians and the writers. Only a deeply insecure society entrusts culture to bureaucratic inquisitors. And only bureaucratic inquisitors see threats emerging in the cradle.

Totalitarian states have always sought to control the kindergartens and the schools and the youth groups, all the better to ensure that the influence of parents on their own children is attenuated. There is the hard totalitarianism that comes by force of arms. Soft totalitarianism comes by way of subsidies, where first the family is embraced by the state, and only then is it suffocated.

The educational world in Quebec does not leave much room to breathe. On religious and cultural matters, the consensus position, as defined by the curriculum apparatchiks, must be taught without exception in all public schools, private schools and even at home. Until now, the preschoolers had escaped the stifling grasp of government. No longer.

As our editorial pointed out, the actual educational results of Quebec daycare are poor. Quebec’s nationalized daycares don’t teach little Quebeckers very much. Now they will ensure that the youngsters know even less.

This article was found at:


COMMENT by Perry Bulwer, January 2, 2011:

Father Raymond J. de Souza's column has it completely backwards. His very first sentence, "It’s never too early to close the minds of the young", exactly describes religious indoctrination. Surely, as a Catholic priest, he must be aware of the Jesuit saying, "Give me the child until he is seven and I will give you the man." Religious indoctrination is all about closing the minds of children, not opening them.

He expresses his fear that the government is "imposing its view on all children", which is simply a lie to deflect from the reality that it is religions like his that do that. They impose their views on children through the use of lies, spiritual fears and threats.

He then states: "Totalitarian states have always sought to control the kindergartens and the schools and the youth groups..." Again he distorts and inverts the truth. Just check out some of the links included with this story. Totalitarian religious groups often resort to intellectual abuse to indoctrinate their children before they can learn to think critically and for themselves.


Some Canadian provinces discriminate against non-Catholics and unbelievers by publicly funding Catholic schools

Battle over ethics course in Quebec schools goes to court - Catholic high school wants exemption

UK theology think tank says it is wrong to exclude God from classroom, superstition and reason should be equal partners

Does religion have any proper role in education?

The liberal state has a duty to ensure that all children acquire the ability to think for themselves

Who is the Real Anti-Christian: the Atheist or the Fundamentalist Christian?

Former governor of church school in UK now says state-funded faith schools are immoral

New Richard Dawkins documentary argues for the abolition of faith schools as a menace to children and society 

British humanist campaign challenges state-funded religious schools

British government amends education bill to allow faith schools to adapt law according to dogma

U.K. school inspectors report that Christian theology and non-religious beliefs not being adequately taught in compulsory religious education classes

Faith schools that indoctrinate children commit child abuse

Strong Secularism: "Religious education can be a form of mental abuse."

Intellectual abuse and suppression of simple childhood pleasures by Islamic fundamentalists common in U.K.

Faith schools ‘will hinder fight against terrorism’

Majority of people in the UK say faith schools divisive

Religious sect takes over school

Islamic schools in U.K. force girls to wear veils, moderate Muslims say children in such schools are being brainwashed

Religious indoctrination thrives in B.C. private schools because education ministry does not vet textbooks or courses

Irish children subjected to religious dogma in order to get an education in school system dominated by Catholic church

Parental rights vs children's rights: debating the role of religious institutions in Irish education system

European Court of Human Rights rules crucifixes in Italian schools violates children's religious freedom to believe or not

German teen expelled from government funded Catholic school after exercising her human right to religious freedom 

Haifa District Court denies parents' request to send children to secular school instead of orthodox school

U.K. zoo that promotes creationism approved by government as destination for school field trips

Queensland state schools will begin teaching creationism as part of history lessons on controversy of human origins

Re-zoning request reveals secretive Exclusive Brethren community in Canada intellectually abusing kids in private school

Intellectual abuse in Exclusive Brethren's government funded schools prevents kids from thinking too much

No University for Exclusive Brethren kids

Australian government gives millions to Exclusive Brethren cult for education that infringes children's rights

Australian government gives $70m to Exclusive Brethren cult schools to indoctrinate children

Australian government gives more millions to Exclusive Brethren cult for small schools that indoctrinate children

Breakout - How I Escaped From The Exclusive Bretheren

Just a sect, Exclusive Brethren is not above the law

No comments:

Post a Comment