4 Jun 2011

Oregon Senate votes to give equal rights to children of religious parents and end faith healing as a legal defense to murder

The Register-Guard    -  Oregon       May 24, 2011

Oregon Senate votes to end faith healing murder defense

Parents could be charged with first-degree manslaughter or murder if the law takes effect

BY TAMI ABDOLLAH | The Associated Press

SALEM — The Oregon Senate voted Monday to eliminate faith healing as a legal defense to murder after repeated deaths of children in a local church community.

The Senate voted 25-5 to approve the measure. It was drafted largely in response to the 2008 deaths of children among members of the Followers of Christ Church in Oregon City, who rely on spiritual treatments instead of medical care.

“The bottom line is that children in Oregon ought to be seeing the kind of health care they need to live, thrive and survive,” said Republican Sen. Bruce Starr of Hillsboro, who sponsored the bill.

Under the measure, prosecutors can seek first-degree manslaughter or murder charges against parents whose children died because they were treated solely with faith.

An Oregon City couple that belongs to the church stands trial this week on criminal mistreatment charges for failing to seek medical care for their infant daughter, now 1½-year old. Jury selection begins today in the case of Timothy and Rebecca Wyland, according to Greg Horner, chief deputy district attorney of Clackamas County. [see related articles links below]

Two other couples from the church have gone to trial. In both cases, the sick children weren’t taken to a doctor but instead were anointed with oil while the family prayed.

Jeff and Marci Beagley were convicted last year of criminally negligent homicide in the 2008 death of their teenage son and sentenced to 16 months in prison. [see related articles links below]

Raylene and Carl Brent Worthington were found not guilty of second-­degree manslaughter in the death of their 15-month-old daughter. Carl Brent Worthington was convicted on a lesser charge of criminal mistreatment and served two months in jail. [see related articles links below]

Attorney Mark Cogan, who represents Timothy Wyland, declined to comment on the bill or to discuss specifics in the case. Cogan also represented Carl Brent Worthington.

The families are members of a small Oregon church that has roots in Kansas but is now based in Oregon City. The church’s small cemetery, not far from the end of the Oregon Trail, has row after row of headstones marking children’s graves.

A listed phone number for the Followers of Christ Church was busy continuously Monday.

The measure, House Bill 2721, expands a 1999 law that eliminated faith healing as a defense from some charges of manslaughter, criminal mistreatment and nonpayment of child support.

It is designed to apply rules equally to all parents whose children die because they didn’t get medical care. Current law makes it tougher to convict parents who do not provide a child with medical care for religious reasons than those who don’t for reasons such as neglect.

“These crimes are based upon the premise that a parent has a legal duty, and they’re failing to provide, whatever it is, medical care or physical care,” Horner said.

Republican Fred Girod of Stayton spoke strongly against the bill, calling it “lousy policy.” He said it needed to be reviewed for the cost and impact on the budget.

Minimum penalties for certain cases considered murders would go from 120 to 300 months in prison and cost an additional $21.88 per day for a temporary prison bed, according to the fiscal impact report.

If the measure becomes law, it means a person could face the same level of punishment as “someone who goes into a liquor store and shoots someone in a robbery,” Girod said. “This is going to the extreme.”

The Oregon House unanimously approved the bill in March with a 59-0 vote. It now returns to the House for vote on changes that would make the bill take effect immediately.

This article was found at:


Faith healing parents guilty but unrepentant, will appeal jail sentence of 6 months for letting child die

U.S. father who prayed while 11 year old daughter suffered and died convicted of murder

Jury Convicts Mother Who Prayed for Daughter Instead of Treating Her Fatal Diabetes

Ex-friend says Wisconsin mother charged with reckless homicide thought illness was sin

Trials for Parents Who Chose Faith Over Medicine

Judge allows charges in prayer death case

Judge in prayer death case: I'm between 'rock and a hard place'

Prosecutors Defend Charges In Prayer Death Case

Parents seek religious exemption for medical neglect murder of daughter

Parents who prayed as daughter died ask judge to drop charges

Healing or homicide? The use of prayer to treat sick children

A Child's Death And a Crisis for Faith

Judge orders parents to stand trial in prayer death case

Faith-based prosecution is first for state, national group says

Faith, medicine collide, and a young girl dies

Law Sanctifies Child Homicide in Name of Faith

Two Wisconsin bills would repeal religious exemption in 'faith healing' cases, but only one protects children

Wisconsin lawmakers reconsider conflicting laws that fail to protect children from faith-based medical neglect

U.S. courts in medical neglect cases give more lenient sentences to faith-healing parents than to non-believers

Oregon bill targets faith healing parents who rely on spiritual treatment as a defense to homicide charges

A century of vaccine paranoia scares many parents away from protecting their children and communities from deadly diseases

Probation for fundamentalist parents who let baby die without medical care, ordered to protect other children from religious beliefs

Pastor and lawyer claim religious persecution of parents charged for allowing 2 year old to die from pneumonia without medical care

Philadelphia 'faith healing' parents face criminal charges for letting 2 year old die without medical care

Claims of persecution ridiculous in societies where Christians have special privileges to indoctrinate children 

Faith healing parents charged with criminal mistreatment of baby with life-threatening tumor on eye

Is it ever OK to seriously harm your child in the name of religion? If so, which religion? 

Should Parents Who Call God Instead of the Doctor Be Punished?

Faith-healing deaths reported in The Oregonian from Nov. 1998 to Jan. 2009

Parents and church members knew infant was suffering, but had no thought of calling a doctor

Prosecutor asks church members: What would it take to call a doctor for ailing child?

Jury acquits parents of all but 1 misdemeanor charge in daughter's "faith healing" murder

Verdict in 'faith healing' baby manslaughter case a miscarriage of justice

Trial in death of infant raises questions of parental rights, religious freedom

Oregon judge tells church members to stop killing children with faith 'healing', parents jailed 16 months for son's death

Teen died agonizing death from ruptured appendix while parents, relatives and church elders did nothing but pray for 3 days

Fundamentalist parents on trial in 'faith healing' murder case claim it was son's free choice to shun medical care

Faith healing parents guilty of criminally negligent homicide in son's death, but exempt from mandatory sentencing due to religious beliefs

U.S. courts in medical neglect cases give more lenient sentences to faith-healing parents than to non-believers

16-year-old with ties to controversial faith healing church, Followers of Christ, found dead

Exploring legal issues courts must consider in cases involving parents' use of faith healing

Courts face new challenges in faith healing cases 

$3 worth of medicine could have accomplished what prayer alone did not

Provision in U.S. healthcare bill endangers children by including pray and faith healing as legitimate clinical medicine

A Child's Death And a Crisis for Faith

Law Sanctifies Child Homicide in Name of Faith

When Parents Call God Instead of the Doctor

Trust in God - A look at 'faith healing' in America.

Little-known religions complicate faith-healing cases

Child deaths test faith-healing exemption

Christian Science theology opposes both medical treatment and diagnosis and demands denial of symptoms

Expert: Change in prayer law would protect Christian Scientists, not kids

1 comment:

  1. Miracle vs. medicine: When faith puts care at risk

    By ALICIA GALLEGOS, amednews staff.
    Sept. 19, 2011.

    Salem, Ore., pediatrician James Lace, MD, will never forget the severely asthmatic patient who could scarcely speak a sentence without gasping for air.

    The 15-year-old girl had endured asthma for years, but her parents refused treatment for her because their religion forbids medical intervention. They believe that only prayer should be used to heal.

    For weeks, Dr. Lace met with the parents at his office and in their home, trying to persuade them to accept medical care. He discussed Bible passages about healing and even prayed with them.

    "I wanted to show them I'm not opposed to their beliefs. ... I wanted to show them that [doctors] are not negating the power of prayer; we're part of that," he said.

    After social workers threatened to place the girl in foster care, the parents relented. Their daughter was prescribed medication, and she gained weight and developed new lung tissue. But once she turned 18, she stopped treatment.

    "She wrote me a letter saying, 'I'm free now. I don't have to see you anymore,' " Dr. Lace said. She wrote, "God wants me to suffer."

    At least 10 child deaths a year in the U.S. are related to faith-based medical neglect.

    read the full article at: