For author, the Jeffs story became personal
by Peg McEntee
First things first. Last week, author Jon Krakauer appeared on CNN and railed at the Utah Supreme Court’s reversal of Warren S. Jeffs’ 2007 convictions of rape as an accomplice.
So for Tuesday’s paper, I wrote a column about what he had said. Later, Krakauer and I talked, and he said he made a “stupid comment” when he blamed the high court’s “close ties to the LDS Church” and the “political basis” of the judgment.
“I apologize to the justices,” he said. “That was not fair.”
But he still believes the ruling, which means a new trial for Jeffs if prosecutors decide to go that way, was a “terrible decision.”
Jeffs was convicted of forcing a 14-year-old girl to marry her 19-year-old cousin. She begged Jeffs not to make her do it, and after the “spiritual” wedding, begged to be released from it. The girl, now grown, claimed her husband had raped her, which led to the charges against Jeffs and his 2007 conviction.
The court agreed with defense claims that the trial judge refused to tell the jurors that to convict Jeffs, they had to find that he knew unwanted sex would take place and that he intended for a rape to occur.
Krakauer doesn’t buy it.
“In order to reverse this, they had to conclude that neglect to issue the proper instructions had a reasonable likelihood that it would affect the jury’s verdict,” he said. “I don’t think that standard was met.
“This was a good judge, a smart jury,” Krakauer said. “They understood who Warren Jeffs was, what his interest was in forcing [the girl] into that marriage.”
Krakauer has reasons behind his words. He’s been acutely interested in the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints since, as he put it, he “stumbled through Short Creek in 1999.” (That settlement is now Hildale, Utah and Colorado City, Ariz.)
“I don’t pretend to be unbiased,” he said. “I’ve spent too much time with the victims” of Jeffs, considered the sect’s prophet and all-powerful leader.
In the early 2000s, Jeffs imposed strict rules on his people — no television, Internet, communication with outsiders. He exiled men he felt were not devout enough. And he broke up families, commonly taking a wife and children from one man and placing them with another.
Finally, when the law started catching up to him, Jeffs bolted, traveling around the country until his arrest in 2006. He was convicted in 2007.
All the while, Krakauer was investigating the FLDS in its home base and its outposts in Texas, South Dakota, Nevada and Colorado.
At one point, Krakauer took under his wing a “lost boy,” one of many Jeffs drove from the community. The boy is now 26 and like a “foster son to me” he said.
And while Krakauer said he’s trying to get away from his obsession with the sect, it’s tough. Living in Colorado, he said, “I hear stuff. Polygamists come through” to visit the young man.
Which is why, as he said, the Supreme Court decision was “crushing to me. I’m emotionally invested in these victims.”
By the way, I checked with Daniel Medwed, a law professor at the University of Utah and graduate of Harvard Law School. He said flawed jury instructions are a “common source” of an appellate court’s reversal of a conviction.
“The prosecution was flawed, and the charges were not quite a fit for the crimes,” he said
If it’s any comfort, Jeffs faces even more serious charges in Texas, where the sect built a community in Eldorado. Jeffs is charged with bigamy and aggravated assault related to his spiritual marriage to a 12-year-old girl. Another count of sexual abuse accuses Jeffs of fathering a child with a girl who was 14 at the time.
Krakauer thinks the evidence in that case “is bomb-proof, riveting and disgusting. I think things look really good there. Texas should and will prosecute.”
I know a thing or two about becoming obsessed with a story. In 2004, I became part of a team that investigated the FLDS for years to come. There were long days, and nights many of us could barely sleep.
I hope Jon Krakauer can find his way out of the FLDS story. He’s recently published a book about Pat Tillman, the former NFL standout and Army Ranger who died by friendly fire in Afghanistan.
As with the FLDS story, he said, “I’m emotionally invested.”
In his work and mine, that’s a given.
This article was found at:
Utah Supreme Court decides to not protect FLDS girls from forced marriage, overturns Warren Jeffs' accomplice to rape convictions
Child 'bride' key witness against Warren Jeffs stunned by court's reversal of rape convictions, fears for safety of FLDS children
Mormon polygamist leader jailed in Utah refuses to sign warrant extraditing him to Texas to face child sex charges
Extradition process started to bring jailed Mormon polygamist leader to Texas for trial after Arizona drops cases against him
Trial begins for brother of jailed Mormon polygamist sect leader, state seeks enhanced penalty for sex assault of child
Mormon polygamist accused of sexual assault wants evidence of polygamy and fraud excluded from trial
Evidence seized during raid on Texas polygamist ranch can be used in sexual assault trials
FLDS polygamist sentenced to 10 years for sexual assault of minor in forced 'marriage'
Mormon polygamist gets 33 years for child sexual assault, defense relied on ridiculous religious freedom argument
Second Mormon polygamist found guilty of child sex assault, jury doesn't buy defense claim of religious persecution
Third Texas polygamist jailed for sex assault, but FLDS spokesman says no contest plea was merely a legal tactic
Fourth Mormon polygamist from Texas compound guilty of bigamy and sex assault of child 'bride', jailed 75 years
First legal finding that bigamy occurred at Mormon fundamentalist compound sees two more polygamists sent to prison
Warren Jeffs' FLDS Church and What I Left Behind
Jeffs's wedding pictures disgust
Texas seeks custody of teen Jeffs allegedly wed
Jeffs' role: Coercion, devotion?
Jurors: Girl’s age was crucial to decision in Warren Jeffs trial
About time, ex-Bountiful member says about Warren Jeffs conviction
Jeffs verdict irrelevant to followers, polygamist community
Sect papers reveal Jeffs total control of followers, even from jail
Religious Beliefs Should Not Protect Polygamist Warren Jeffs
Warren Jeffs Still Dominant Force Even After Conviction
Polygamist leader Jeffs still a force from jail
JEFFS BOMBSHELL: Says he was "immoral" with sister, daughter in jailhouse tapes
Listening to the Lord: Jeffs exerted 24-7 control over FLDS faithful
When Men Become Gods: Mormon Polygamist Warren Jeffs, His Cult of Fear, and the Women Who Fought Back
New Book on Warren Jeffs' Polygamy Sect Provides Insight into Lives of Women Enslaved by Fundamentalist Group
Texas polygamist trial set to start, advocate says women nothing but pimps giving their daughters to perverts
Texas doctor protesting conviction of FLDS polygamist for sexual assault says law should allow sex with minors
Hate mail from Mormon polygamists doesn't faze Texas lawmaker who crafted laws to protect girls from religious abuse